What that rustling in your walls actually is
That soft, papery crackle behind your drywall is almost always carpenter ants excavating tunnels. They chew galleries into wood to build their nest, and the sound carries through the hollow wall cavity like a speaker.
It's loudest at night, usually from dusk to a few hours after dark. That's when the colony is most active and the rest of the house is quiet.
Here's the part people get wrong: carpenter ants don't eat the wood. They chew it out and dump it. So the damage is slower than termites, but a mature colony left alone for years can still hollow out important framing.
The good news is this is fixable. The catch is that finding and killing the actual nest usually takes a licensed pro, which is why we rate this problem pro-friendly rather than DIY.
Why carpenter ants picked your wall
Carpenter ants don't dig into just any wood. They go for wood that's already softened by water, which is why nearly every wall infestation ties back to a moisture problem.
Think slow roof leaks, sweating supply lines behind a kitchen or bath, a leaky window flashing, or a rotted door sill. The ants follow the damp, then set up shop.
Sometimes the wall nest is a satellite. The parent colony lives outside in a stump, a woodpile, or a dead branch, and workers travel a trail inside. If you treat only the wall, the source keeps refilling it.
Timing matters too. A colony that moved in during fall can go quiet all winter, then suddenly get loud in early spring. People swear it's brand new when really it's been there for months.
And occasionally the culprit isn't ants at all. Mice in the insulation make a similar rustle. The difference is character: ants are a fine steady crackle, rodents are heavier bursts with gnawing and the odd thump.